British Pregnancy Advisory Service logo

3 February 2015

Commentary: Our MPs must not sleep walk towards abortion restrictions

An excellent article by Lisa Hallgarten in the New Statesman.

Hallgarten writes:

‘It’s an election year, so perhaps it would be surprising if nuance and complexity were in evidence in the House of Commons. In this context we should be very concerned about a late amendment, snuck into the Serious Crime Bill, to outlaw sex-selective abortion. Pro-choice MPs may be seduced by the idea that this is a feminist amendment. They may be convinced that it will not change anything. They are likely to fear their voters concluding that they don’t care about the plight of female foetuses. But those who vote for this amendment may be unwittingly waving the white flag in the first battle in a long-term war to limit access to safe legal abortion in the UK.

‘There is no reliable evidence to support the view that women are routinely having abortions for reasons of sex selection. There is even less evidence to suggest that a sex-selective abortion ban would be effective in ending the phenomenon. The amendment does not address any of the complex economic, social, or cultural practices and beliefs that create a boy-preference in some communities; and, of course, it will remain possible to access an abortion in the UK or elsewhere without specifying sex selection as the reason.

‘In an off-the-record conversation, a seasoned feminist campaigner from the South Asian community admits to me that a ban wouldn’t work for just these reasons. Nonetheless, she supports a ban “because it doesn’t need to work”, she tells me, “just passing a law will send a strong message”.

‘So the ban is nothing more than a grand gesture, but unfortunately it is a grand gesture with potentially catastrophic consequences for women’s ongoing access to abortion. Although an earlier iteration of this amendment was described by its proposer – anti-abortion MP Fiona Bruce – as a “clarification of the law” in fact passing this amendment fundamentally undermines essential principles of existing law and practice…’

Read the full article here:

Our MPs must not sleep walk towards abortion restrictions. They should oppose any legislation that jeopardises women’s full and equal access to all reproductive health services. By Lisa Hallgarten, New Statesman, 29 January 2015.

Also read:

Britain’s Abortion Law: What it says, and why. BPAS, 2013

Reproductice Review topic archive: Abortion laws

Reproductice Review topic archive: ‘Sex selection’ claims

tweet